Main Street in crisis – A national emergency deserves a national response

Commentary

Posted 6/17/25

Main Street embodies more than nostalgia; it represents a dynamic system of commerce, identity, and...

You must be a member to read this story.

Join our family of readers for as little as $5 per month and support local, unbiased journalism.


Already have an account? Log in to continue. Otherwise, follow the link below to join.

Please log in to continue

Log in
I am anchor

Main Street in crisis – A national emergency deserves a national response

Commentary

Posted

As a Director of Okeechobee Main Street, I witness firsthand the challenges our small businesses face daily. From Okeechobee, Florida, to countless downtowns nationwide, Main Street is in a state of emergency—grappling with razor-thin margins, unpredictable supply chains, and fluctuating consumer demand. These establishments are not merely businesses; they are the economic and cultural backbone of America.

The recent Spring 2025 Main Street America Survey, encompassing responses from 1,587 small businesses across over 500 communities, reveals a troubling scenario: confidence among small business owners has plummeted to its lowest since the survey’s inception in 2022. Only 40% rated their business outlook at 8 or higher on a 10-point scale. The pressing concerns include rising input costs (72%), decreasing customer spending (68%), and apprehensions about new tariffs (50%). These issues manifest in real-time through shipment delays, escalating insurance premiums, and the stark reality that 65% of respondents report earning insufficient income to cover basic expenses.

Main Street businesses operate on lean margins and are inherently vulnerable. Over half employ only 1–2 full-time staff, with more than 90% having fewer than 20 employees. Many depend on unpaid assistance from family and friends to remain operational, and the majority generate less than $200,000 in annual revenue. These are our local coffee shops, hardware stores, and boutiques—the very establishments that sponsor community events and youth sports teams.

To address this crisis effectively, we must consider the following actions:

• Expand and simplify access to capital: Streamline existing SBA programs and broaden micro-loan initiatives for businesses earning under $250,000 annually.

• Enhance federal grant visibility and outreach: Fund local grant navigators through chambers of commerce and Main Street programs to assist small business owners in accessing available resources.

• Promote rent stabilization and storefront ownership: Offer incentives or matching funds for small business co-ops or municipal ownership programs, enabling long-standing tenants to purchase their commercial spaces.

• Provide clarity on trade policy: Establish a stable, long-term trade policy, particularly concerning small-volume importers, to reduce uncertainty.

At the local level, we can implement measures to fortify our communities:

• Establish local business resilience hubs: Collaborate with Main Street programs and economic development councils to create centralized support centers offering mentorship, training, legal aid, and technological assistance.

• Promote local procurement and “Buy Local” incentives: Encourage municipalities to prioritize local sourcing for government contracts and incentivize consumers through rewards programs or local tax rebates.

• Address zoning and permitting bottlenecks: Simplify permitting processes, expedite occupancy approvals, and clarify code guidelines to make entrepreneurship more accessible.

• Offer tax abatements or oncentives: Provide tax relief to landlords who maintain stable rents for small businesses in historic districts or underserved neighborhoods.

Furthermore, it’s imperative to provide business owners with ongoing education in digital marketing, inventory management, HR practices, and grant application navigation. Regional networking opportunities can also foster mentorship and collaboration, strengthening the collective resilience of Main Street businesses.

Healthy small businesses are the bedrock of local economies, attracting larger investments and cultivating thriving communities. Investors seeking resilient, long-term growth should closely monitor small business health indicators and advocate for policies that empower local enterprises.

Main Street embodies more than nostalgia; it represents a dynamic system of commerce, identity, and upward mobility. However, it remains fragile. We have surpassed the warning signs. To safeguard America’s heartland, coordinated and strategic action is imperative—now.

LTE, Letter to the Editor, Main Street, business, small, mom and pop, mom-and-pop, downtown, Gary L. Stark
x